Sunday, March 14, 2010

Bound by the "BOND"

Employee bonds are becoming the order of the day especially for employees who join at a junior level and particularly when a lot of training and development is required in order to make them “useful” to the company. Well, then are these kind of bonds justified? The answer to that is not that simple. Before seeing whether they are justified or not, let’s see whether they’re actually enforceable in India or not. The main reason why companies use such kind of bonds is to prevent entry level employees from learning newer technology etc. and then moving on to some other organization. But frankly speaking and as pointed out by Sudeep, big companies do not use these bonds. It is probably because it is sometimes the end of the road for the employee who wants to move on to a bigger organization but has reached the likes of Microsoft or Google where the road sadly but truly, ends. This concept makes sense for industries like Aviation and Medicine where there are really huge training costs involved. I remember a friend of mine joining Air India as a pilot who had to sign a bond of 5 years to stay with the organization or payment of a sum of Rs. 20 Lacs in case he decides to leave earlier. The stakes are high in this case and also that word of mouth might spoil his reputation as a professional among other airlines. But in the ever so large and volatile IT industry, where these bonds are so casually used, enforcing them becomes a pain for the organization. The main reason behind this is the additional legal charges that the company will have to incur apart from the investment of time and legal manpower. Despite this, how does an employee exactly get away without paying the bond amount? Well many times the new employer agrees to pay this sum. And other times what an employee does who is already aware of the loophole stated above, is that he simply collects the salary of the current month, puts in his resignation letter and leaves the company. He very well knows that in India the pursuit for the bond amount ends at a few e-mails and phone calls. However there is a catch to this. The employee is not given his full and final settlement amount and the relieving letters that some reputed organizations ask for at the time of joining. But then again there is always some or the other way out of this pickle.

So is this justified i.e. the concept of making new employees sign bonds? Well I think it certainly is. Although quite a few of entry level employees (mind you the bond concept does not work for senior level employees) break these bonds, the majority do not do so as they are not sure of the outcome. So this tool is effective to an extent in order to retain the talent that an organization develops by investing time and money on its training. The issue here is that an employee is never actually allowed to read the bond before he signs it. So in essence the employee doesn’t really have a choice before he signs it.

But whatever practices an organization may adopt, it is effectively to protect its interests. Finding new talent, investing in them and then letting them go with their new acquired knowledge is not exactly a way in which a capitalistic economy may prosper.

Bond for the Bonded

Companies today are empowered by the body of law to carry out their businesses profitably by adopting any methods that are recognized as legal by the constitution of the country they operate in; to protect their business interests. So if a company has invested money in developing a specific technology, skill set or a unique training program then it has the right to demand financial/operational return from the same in terms of monetary reimbursements or as a legal obligation of the employee. But in fact, companies tend to take this as an opportunity to squeeze out the best out of an employee.

The rise of the BOND in India:

The rise of the bond can be attributed to the highly vibrant IT sector which was booming with opportunities with the start of the new century. With the unique skill set required for this industry and low availability then, there was an urgent need for sustained development of quality workforce. With huge amount of investments going into the workforce development, it was absolutely necessary for these IT firms to retain the trained workforce who are in high demand outside. With a fair argument in asking for the return on their investment, they came up with the “BOND”, the “Employment Bond”.

The “James” in Employment Bond:

I wonder why James Bond and Employment Bond share the same surname. Employment bond, like the British navy commander is a civil servant of the company who works for the Ministry of Defense, defending its land (business) against attrition of skilled employees.

The employment bond (like JB) is an agent for the company (nation) who works in situations caused by buoyant industry (inter-national) situation/circumstances. It requires soul searching from both employees and the companies and helps in maintaining a mutually beneficial association (international peace and security) between both the parties. The employees (other nations) should understand the compulsions and challenges of running a business (nation with peace) and strive to maintain a long and productive association with the company (internationally).

On the other hand the employment bond (like JB) has a slightly positive side also. The employment bond is also legally committed (to the famous "bond gals") to retain the employees until the completion of the contract period (until they are ready to date). It cannot terminate the contract (relationship) for reasons other than gross act of indiscipline (cheating on him), causing loss to the company (his mission) or the inability to continue business (satisfy him) for economic (emotional/sexual) reasons.

Why “NO” to this BOND?

It is quite evident nowadays that no job aspirant is ready to accept/sign the Employment Bond. But they have to take up jobs in order to earn their livelihood and thus have no other option but sign the BOND. Seeing the flipside, most young professionals should feel responsible and understand the advantages of long term association with one company. They should realize that they would grow along with the employer/company and not hop jobs frequently. Summing it up, say “YES” to the employment bond as long as the company/employer is providing a vibrant workplace, professional work environment and a challenging job.

Employment Bond

At the time of joining the company an employee is zealous to serve the company and in the hope of long term relationship and gaining seniority with promotions in pay and rank, certain events change the working and the mind of the employee and this is but natural.

While joining, the employee undertakes to serve the company for a fixed period and in breach agrees to pay a certain amount. This amount is covered under a bond and on resignation the company demands such amount.
But most employees are unaware of the legal implications in the event they leave the job without relieving letter and what action the company may take against them in such a situation.

As for the impact on career is concerned, there are certain employers who understand the plight of the employees and they consider their employment even without asking for relieve from neither the former company nor the experience letter, there are other such companies who purely follow such rules as demanding relieving and experience certificates.
Employer's perspective

I don’t think the practice is wrong, as when the company is putting so much investment/effort/time into training and developing an individual, and if the individual instead of being fruitful to the company uses the training imparted to him for his own professional growth; then it's but natural and within the purview of professionalism to have him stay put to the company's cause for a certain period of time.
It's that much more important to bind an employee when commitment, integrity and honesty are on the doldrums and people only want to take advantage of their increasing demand in the market place.
Employee Perspective: As there are no other best options available, go with the company's bond.
But there are some employers who just want to hold employees as if the employee has been bought for some worth and make them work day and night (as he cannot leave the company in bond period). They want to save some money on employees by paying less salary in this bond period.

Some of the typical clauses in a common employment bond are:
1. If you leave job, you will have to give a 1/2/3 months notice.
2. You cannot join a company that is into a similar line of business. (Non-Compete clause).
3. You will have to pay to the company a particular sum if you are leaving the organization.


I feel if company environment, remuneration and growth is good then there is no need for any bond as no employee would prefer leaving such company as long as some other reasons don’t operate.
Let us understand that people work by choice; if you love someone don't sign a bond with him and there would be reasonable probability that he stays with you.
And the moment you sign a bond with him, the love is lost from the relationship, and even the probability of him staying with you would tend to ZERO.
Freedom is the best bond.Hence getting an employee to sign a bond (especially fresher’s) is more to act as a deterrent and discourage the employees to quit within a short duration.
Instead, you may want to choose to add a clause in his/her offer and/or appointment letter which says that should the employee choose to leave the company within an x period then he/she will be required to reimburse the company the cost of training which will be equivalent to x amount of the employee's ctc.
I agree and I personally believe that signing a bond for training purpose is ok but signing a bond while recruiting is a direct veto on right to livelihood.

Also any company cannot hold the relieving of its employee as until then the employee is on the rolls of their employee and the right to salary and perks are accrued.

The Indian Constitution and Indian Contract Act
Bond was a way devised by some wise HR person USA. As per the law and regulation of USA this kind of arrangement between the employee and employer was acceptable.
But companies practice this bond culture in Indian market without understanding the Legal, Social, and cultural back ground.
As per the Indian Statute bonded labor system was long abolished and no bond can force any person to work against the employees wishes
As per the Article 19 of the Indian Constitution the write work is a fundamental right, and under no circumstance does the Fundamental rights under Article 19 be waived by any person nor can any person be forced to do something that’s amounting to the violation of the rights mentioned under Article 19.
As per the Indian Contract Act contracts entered between two parties if is one sided then such contract would be null and void. Most of the Bonds are one sided i.e. in favor of the employer.

Again as per the Indian Contract Act no contract can be enforced on any person if the contract which is being so enforced causes any harm to the person on whom it is enforced and if performed would violate principles of natural justices.
Hence signing a bond is justifiable in cases where the company imparts huge capital investments, time and efforts on employees to groom them as future managers. However if the company provides good career growth, competitive package and friendly working environment then employees will have a strong bonding with the company and will stay forever.

Has the Bond in you bonded by a bond?

Let me first tell you a story- the story of my childhood friend-a bond who was bonded by a bond. And no marks for guessing the firm- its ASATYAM . The bond gets the joining letter. Rather being ecstatic, he was sad because ASATYAM had asked him to pay Rs 200000 to get bonded with a bond for 2 years. He went for the loan arrangement of SBI. Then received the training for 5 months after which ASATYAM said he would get a project. He waited and meanwhile was pushed on to the bench. He waited and waited for project calls, alas none came. Then Raju made that (in) famous confession and all dreams of our bond got shattered. Still he waited and finally got a project call after 2 years and 2 months.

Way to cover costs? Well many of my friends have said that employment bonds are a means to cover a portion of training costs (I would say variable training costs) by the firm. The bonds are not only meant to recover investment made, but also discourage the employee from switching to another company immediately with the knowledge gained in current organization.

But in the above story Mr Bond was made to sit on the Bench for 21 months. During this time he had got many other firms’ offers but couldn’t switch because of the Rs 200000 caveat. But after 26 months he gets a call for a project and is trained again for 2 months on a new technology (additional costs). So did ASATYAM really recover the training cost? I guess it incurred more costs as Mr Bond was playing table tennis and swimming all these 26 months and he was being paid the full salary to do so.

I think this story suggests that some of the Indian management practices are archaic in nature and I agree with Ashish. These have to evolve. In this case it would have been mutually beneficial had ASATYAM not bonded Mr Bond . He would have gone to another firm and not waste his time on bench and ASATYAM would have incurred much lesser costs.

Culture & best practices and an emotional bond-Some of the most respected companies don’t have employment bonds. Microsoft & Google don’t have. And these companies pay 3-4 times the salary paid by SWITCH( Satyam Wipro,Infy,Tcs, Cogni and HCL). Their training costs are exorbitantly high. But it is something about the culture and best practices. They foster such an environment that employees develop an emotional bond with the firm and happy employees means more profits. This bond is a much robust and stronger bond than the employment bond and in a real sense it helps in curbing attrition. As Subra had correctly pointed out, students don’t want to join firms with employment bonds and rather love to join such firm like MS, Google or CA for this reason.

Why to put the sackles ?

Firms want to cover the training costs and hedge against attrition. And so they come out with employment bonds. But we have already seen above, how counterproductive it can become. I think we need to tweak the practices. In situations where a bond has to be there, we can follow practices of global firms. Mr Vipul Singh- Head HR Hyderabad Accenture says-“We at Accenture tread very cautiously with bonds. We don’t want it in the first place but in India we have to go ahead with this practice. But ours is different than the others. We try to develop an attachment with the employees using our culture and vision. We know using bonds we cannot put a cap on intellectual capital. We are very flexible with the terms of the bonds. Our bonds vary based on the technologies on which the software engineers have been trained on. It’s Rs 150000 for ERPS and Data Warehousing and as low as Rs 25000 for UNIX and C++ for a 1 year period. Also our bonds work on a prorated basis. If he/she quits before 6 months, he/she has to pay the entire amount. If the employee has worked for more than 6 months, he/she would be asked to pay the amount corresponding to the no. of months left wrt the bond period. Moreover we give relaxations if the employee didn’t get a project call in this period.” Having worked with the firm, I can say Accenture does practice this culture. I think other firms can follow such global healthy practices and learn more in this regard.

These were some of the inputs I could bring in. Thank you for reading.

Employment bond is a contract made between the employer and employee .In addition to the terms and conditions of employment it also contains special clause for conditions when the employer either offers special training to enhance the employee's competency and utility to the company or defrays special expenses in deputation abroad etc. All this requires substantial amount of investment.

Since the employer has made an investment in the employee he feels and probably is justified to get appropriate contributions (value addition) from the employee in return. Hence the bonds are drafted to bind the employee serve to the company for a defined period (within which the employer feel the money invested would have been recovered adequately).

There cannot be any mathematical formula or generalized rule to decide the period for which the employee may not leave employment and the value of the bond he may be required to sign. It should be reasonable and be seen by the courts as such if there be any litigation in future. Experience tells that it is uneconomical to enforce the bond; it is time consuming
and at best a psychological deterrent only.

That might explain why companies sometimes do not follow up with the employees who break bonds and move out especially when the employee is moving for higher studies. However when the employee is of significant importance to the firm employer might choose to enforce the bond. However in that case the bond needs to be proved in the court as a balanced one and which is reasonable in scope. Since all employees had freedom of mobility the bonds might not be enforceable. Employers need to have offer better motivational tools to retain employees than attempt to do so through bonds.

BONDED. AT WILL.

As pointed out earlier, companies have many different reasons to draft these employment contracts.

• To lower the attrition rate.
• To recover the amount they invested in the training.
• To not to lose the knowledge workers.

But let’s look at this from the employee’s point of view. Employment bonds usually cover the first 1 to 2 years of one’s service period. For a person to leave the job during this period, the reasons are usually to go for higher studies or for better job opportunities. So if they are ready to pay the amount to release themselves of the bond, that means they consider their other options to be much more lucrative.But do they really get the worth of the bond amount they are paying? Do they actually make use of the knowledge and skill they develop during the training?

Let’s take an example of a software engineer. During his training he developed expertise in some assembly language. Now he gets through an MBA entrance exam,leaves the employer and joins a management course. I don’t think his proficiency in the language he learnt is going to be of much use here. But of course his involvement with live projects (if any) during his tenure with the company will help him in applying his experience in his new field. But does that give him value for his money? In most cases the answer is no. One or two years of work is too less time to gain some substantial quantity of understanding of the real business scenario.

As we can see, employment comes as an entire package; full of bonds, contracts, horrifying repercussions if contracts are not followed religiously till the last word etc. And you can’t even complain because it’s employment at will after all.

BOND – the order of the day

In today’s world loyalty has become a rare commodity and when it comes to employment it has become a thing of the past. Some 15 years back people had very little opportunities to change companies and as a result of it they were forced to be loyal to their employers and this was a era when employment contracts were un heard of since companies knew that the employee has got no other go and also the employee knew that there is not enough opportunity to go to some other company.
With the advent of globalisation the scene completely changed, giving some power to the employee. Most of the people have got 2 to 3 offers to choose from and even after choosing one and joining a company they are on the lookout for the other job which will pay them more, that more can be even 2000 pm extra. When this has become the case, companies in an effort to prevent the uncontrolled flow of employees to other companies have come up with employment bonds. Through the bonds what an organisation asks an employee is
“Please be loyal to us for a certain limited period so whatever training that we gave to you is justified”
In most of the cases the bond period is 1 or 2 years, but in very rare cases as sir has mentioned it is 5 years. Also most of the companies do not stress up on the bond if you are going for higher studies and you are breaking the bond when you have already served about 80% of your bond period.
From this we can see that the purpose of the bond is not to
• Instil a sense of loyalty in the employee (there are certain things which money can’t buy)
• As a means of gaining control over the employee by the employer (many people break the bond and pay the money when they are sure that the financial obligations are outweighed by something bigger)
Whereas the purpose of the bond is to
• The companies can make sure that employees serve at least the minimum period of time so the employer can get a positive return on the amount of money they spent on training the employee.
• The bonds will make the employees to think before they make a switch, but bond per se won’t prevent attrition but it will just reduce the loss the companies make because of the attrition
We can say that bond is inevitable in a knowledge economy.